Crumbl Cookies Menu – Henrietta, NY

Crumbl was founded in Logan, Utah, in 2017 by cousins Jason McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley and has grown to more than 1,000 bakeries in the U.S. and Canada. It is known for oversized cookies sold in its signature pink box; the menu pairs a set of always-available classic flavors with rotating specialty flavors that change every week, so most items vary by week.

16 signature items across 3 categories. Chain menus vary by location and season, so the Henrietta store may not carry every item.

Classic Cookies (always available)

Milk Chocolate ChipWarm, oversized cookie loaded with milk chocolate chips; Crumbl's original signature flavor.
Classic Pink SugarChilled vanilla sugar cookie topped with a thick swirl of pink almond-vanilla frosting.
SnickerdoodleSoft cookie rolled in cinnamon sugar, often finished with a cinnamon frosting swirl.
Brownie BatterFudgy chocolate cookie with brownie-batter flavor and chocolate topping.
Chocolate CrumbChocolate cookie topped with a cookies-and-cream style crumb and cream frosting.
Celebration CakeSprinkle-filled birthday cake style cookie with vanilla frosting and colorful sprinkles.

Frequently Returning Rotating Flavors

Kentucky Butter CakeButter cake cookie soaked with a warm buttery glaze; a rotating flavor that returns periodically.
CornbreadCornbread-style cookie topped with honey butter; one of the most frequently returning weekly flavors.
Sea Salt ToffeeBrown butter cookie with toffee bits and flaky sea salt, a regular in the weekly rotation.
Biscoff LavaCookie-butter cookie with a molten Biscoff center and Biscoff cookie crumbs on top.
Cookies & CreamChocolate or vanilla cookie loaded with OREO pieces and cream frosting; OREO-based flavors return often.

Ordering Formats

Single CookieOne oversized cookie served in Crumbl's signature pink box, warm or chilled depending on flavor.
4-Pack and 6-PackMix-and-match pink boxes of the week's flavors for sharing.
Party BoxLarge box of a dozen assorted cookies for groups and events.
Mini CookiesSmaller versions of the weekly flavors sold in multi-cookie packs.
CateringBulk cookie orders for offices and events, available for pickup or delivery.

Check the hoursSee if Crumbl Cookies is open right now Get directions100 Marketplace Dr, Ste 120 More cookie shopsCompare with others near you

Crumbl Cookies Henrietta Menu

Classic Cookies (always available)

Frequently Returning Rotating Flavors

Ordering Formats